What is being discussed in the video? Explain your answer.
The video is discussed about what is statelessness. In the video said that stateless people are people who don’t have nationality of any country. It is also explained that stateless people may not get ID card, passport, or any other proof nationality doing. They also may not be able to travel to another countries to see a doctor, to find a place to live, even to get married, and the worst thing is many of stateless people are the victim from abuses and violence.
What is the speaker’s main purpose? Explain your answer.
The speaker want to share some information about statelessness. She explained about the meaning and also the bad effects of not being stateless.
How trustworthy is this video? Who is the speaker? What is the source? Do you think the source and the speaker are trustworthy?
I think this video is trustworthy because the video is from UNHCR’s youtube channel. It is a global organization dedicated to saving lives and protecting the rights of refugees, forcibly displaced communities and stateless people.
What the speaker’s attitude or tone towards the subject? Does he/she seem to agree or disagree with it? Explain your answer.
The speaker seem to agree with the topic. She agree that statelessness is a big problem.
Does the speaker put forward valid or strong arguments? How does he/she support the key points? Explain your answer.
Because this video is from UNHCR, they have discussed and report so many cases about refugee news, people who were expelled from their country, and others. So, I think they know what’s going on out there that not many people know about. And they also work to protect and uphold the rights of refugees and stateless people, so I think their argument is quite strong.
Explain how this article will help contribute to your larger group project.
(Ariestu, I. P. D. (2018). The State Responsibilities Relating to Human Rights Violations to The People with Stateless Persons Status in Rohingnya Crisis. Jurnal Magister Hukum Udayana (Udayana Master Law Journal), 7(2), 154-164. DOI: 10.24843/JMHU.2018.v07.i02 .p2)
this article help me to know more about what is statelessness and The article also discusses about Rohingya Muslims who have to become immigrants and lose their citizenship
What is being discussed in the video? Explain your answer.
in the video contains the story of a man who has no citizenship or stateless who lives in Malaysia. He became stateless because his parents did not have a marriage certificate and his mother was a foreigner. He also tells about how difficult it is to live stateless in Malaysia. He finds it difficult to get a job because he does not have an identity card and a bank account. He was also bullied when he was in school.
What is the speaker’s main purpose? Explain your answer.
the purpose of the video is that the boy wants to share a story about what it’s like to be stateless. He also hopes that the Malaysian government can handle this case.
How trustworthy is this video? Who is the speaker? What is the source? Do you think the source and the speaker are trustworthy?
I think this video is trustworthy because the speaker is actually stateless people. He shares the story of how he has been feeling all this time
What the speaker’s attitude or tone towards the subject? Does he/she seem to agree or disagree with it? Explain your answer.
from the way he spoke, the speaker showed that he agreed that being stateless was difficult. there are many things he can’t do because he doesn’t have citizenship
Does the speaker put forward valid or strong arguments? How does he/she support the key points? Explain your answer.
I think he has a strong argument because he is the object being talked about. he experienced firsthand how to live stateless
Explain how this article will help contribute to your larger group project.
Allerton, Catherine (2017). Contested Statelessness in Sabah, Malaysia: Irregularity and the Politics of Recognition. Journal of Immigrant & Refugee Studies, 15(3), 250–268. doi:10.1080/15562948.2017.1283457
the article made me understand more that getting an identity is quite difficult, sometimes they are even rejected for no apparent reason. being stateless is also difficult because they can’t be free to do things that ‘normal’ people can do
What is being discussed in the video? Explain your answer.
There are two important instruments of international law regarding statelessness that you need to know about were established in international law after the Second World War. The first is the 1954 convention relating to the status of stateless persons defines who stateless persons are and the minimum set of rights granted to them . And the second is The 1961 Convention on reducing statelessness is to ensure that states take steps to reduce and prevent statelessness. One such measure is to ensure that all previously stateless children acquire citizenship and that people do not lose their citizenship in the future.
What is the speaker’s main purpose? Explain your answer.
its aim is to inform people about the rights of statelessness
How trustworthy is this video? Who is the speaker? What is the source? Do you think the source and the speaker are trustworthy?
this video is trustworthy because the video is from channel UNHCR Teaching About Refugees
, that is UNHCR’s youtube channel. It is a global organization dedicated to saving lives and protecting the rights of refugees, forcibly displaced communities and stateless people.
What the speaker’s attitude or tone towards the subject? Does he/she seem to agree or disagree with it? Explain your answer.
the speaker seems to agree, because there are no sentences indicating disagreement in the video
Does the speaker put forward valid or strong arguments? How does he/she support the key points? Explain your answer.
Because this video is from the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, they have discussed and reported on a variety of issues including refugees, persons who have been ejected from their nation, and others. So, I believe they are aware of what is going on in the world that few others are aware of. They also fight to safeguard and promote the rights of refugees and stateless individuals, thus I believe they have a compelling case.
Explain how this article will help contribute to your larger group project.
This article provides me with more detailed information on the right to statelessness. the article also provides some examples related to the topic and makes me understand better
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40802-018-0116-7#Sec2
Owen, D. (2018). On the right to have nationality rights: statelessness, citizenship and human rights. Netherlands International Law Review, 65(3), 299-317.
What is being discussed in the video? Explain your answer.
in the video it is explained about what things can cause someone to lose their citizenship. These things include, discrimination in nationality laws (e.g. racial, religious or gender), conflict between and gaps in nationality laws and State succession, lack of birth registration, Risks of statelessness can also arise in situations of displacement
What is the speaker’s main purpose? Explain your answer.
the speaker wants to convey information about how a person can be stateless
How trustworthy is this video? Who is the speaker? What is the source? Do you think the source and the speaker are trustworthy?
the video is still from UNHCR. I take a lot of videos from there because I think it’s a pretty reliable source. they also make a lot of videos about statelessness
What the speaker’s attitude or tone towards the subject? Does he/she seem to agree or disagree with it? Explain your answer.
the speaker feels that statelessness is a serious problem because this problem is difficult to resolve. If the parents do not have citizenship, then the child is most likely not to have one either
Does the speaker put forward valid or strong arguments? How does he/she support the key points? Explain your answer.
Because this video is from the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR), they have discussed and reported on a variety of issues including refugees, persons who have been ejected from their nation, and others. So, I believe they are aware of what is going on in the world that few others are aware of. They also fight to safeguard and promote the rights of refugees and stateless individuals, thus I believe they have a compelling case.
Explain how this article will help contribute to your larger group project.
the article helped me understand more about the topic being discussed. At first I didn’t really understand how gender discrimination could make a person statelessness and it was explained in the article
What is being discussed in the video? Explain your answer.
the video is talking about Syrian refugees that forced into statelessness. One in every five persons in Lebanon is now a Syrian refugee. Around five years ago, the country closed its borders, and the government has become more restrictive in giving resident permits. Hundreds of thousands of Syrian refugees have been forced to flee their homes, unable to travel or work as a result. Children born to undocumented parents are at risk of becoming stateless.
What is the speaker’s main purpose? Explain your answer.
to report and provide information to the audience about the situation of Syrian refugees in Lebanon.
How trustworthy is this video? Who is the speaker? What is the source? Do you think the source and the speaker are trustworthy?
the video is from channel France 24. France 24 is a French state-owned international news television network based in Paris.
What the speaker’s attitude or tone towards the subject? Does he/she seem to agree or disagree with it? Explain your answer.
The speaker spoke in a serious tone and during the interview with the stateless there, they seemed angry because they were treated badly
Does the speaker put forward valid or strong arguments? How does he/she support the key points? Explain your answer.
yes, the speaker is a news anchor so before delivering the news, there must have been observations first. The video also shows interviews of several refugees.
Explain how this article will help contribute to your larger group project.
This article helps me understand more about that someone can be ‘forced’ to lose their citizenship. This article explains about Rohingya Muslims who are stateless because their country doesn’t want to recognize them and rejects them. they are indirectly forced into statelessness.
(Sahana, Mehebub; Jahangir, Selim; Anisujjaman, MD. (2019). Forced Migration and the Expatriation of the Rohingya: A Demographic Assessment of Their Historical Exclusions and Statelessness. Journal of Muslim Minority Affairs, 39(1), 44–60. doi:10.1080/13602004.2019.1587952 )
What is being discussed in the video? Explain your answer.
Two important instruments of international law regarding statelessness that you need to know: The 1954 convention relating to the status of stateless persons defines who a stateless person is and the set of minimum rights they are granted.1961 Convention on the Reduction of statelessness. The 1961 Convention requires that States establish safeguards in legislation to address statelessness occurring at birth or later in life.
What is the speaker’s main purpose? Explain your answer.
The speaker wants to share information about the legal framework for statelessness.
How trustworthy is this video? Who is the speaker? What is the source? Do you think the source and the speaker are trustworthy?
I think this video is trustworthy because the video is from UNHCR’s youtube channel. It is a global organization dedicated to saving lives and protecting the rights of refugees, forcibly displaced communities and stateless people.
What the speaker’s attitude or tone towards the subject? Does he/she seem to agree or disagree with it? Explain your answer.
from the tone of his voice, the speakers seem to agree that statelessness also deserves their protection and rights
Does the speaker put forward valid or strong arguments? How does he/she support the key points? Explain your answer.
Since this video is from the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR), they have discussed and reported on various issues including refugees, people being evicted from their countries, and others. So I believe they are aware of what is going on in the world that few others are aware of. They also fight to protect and promote the rights of refugees and stateless individuals. they must also understand about the rights of statelessness
Explain how this article will help contribute to your larger group project.
the article provided me with information about the legal framework of stateless addresses. the explanation in the article is more detailed and mentions other legal frameworks other than those mentioned in the video.
(Background Note on gender equality, nationality laws and statelessness 2014- UNHCR (https://www.unhcr.org/4f5886306.pdf))
What is being discussed in the video? Explain your answer.
The video discusses how to stop statelessness. In 2014, UNHCR launched the #IBelong campaign to reduce statelessness. they hope that statelessness can be stopped in 2024. Kyrgyzstan is the first country to meet that goal. they grant 13,000 people citizenship within 5 years. and people hope other countries can emulate Kyrgyzstan
What is the speaker’s main purpose? Explain your answer.
speakers discussed and debated how to reduce statelessness.
How trustworthy is this video? Who is the speaker? What is the source? Do you think the source and the speaker are trustworthy?
The speakers are Melanie Khanna, Chief of UNHCR’s Statelessness Section; Julia Harrington Reddy, Director of the Open Society Justice; Jawad Fairooz, Chairman of SALAM for Democracy and Human Rights and Amal de Chickera, Co-Director at the Institute on Statelessness and Inclusion and presented by David Foster. the video is from Roundtable. Roundtable is a discussion program where guests debate the news (wikipedia). and i think the speakers are trustworthy because they are people who are experts and quite experienced in their fields
What the speaker’s attitude or tone towards the subject? Does he/she seem to agree or disagree with it? Explain your answer.
The tone used by the speaker is serious. there are some parts that show disagreement, such as when they discussed the #IBelong campaign, because according to one of the speakers it was quite a difficult thing to do.
Does the speaker put forward valid or strong arguments? How does he/she support the key points? Explain your answer.
yes, they debate and discuss based on available data and facts. they provide concrete examples to strengthen their argument
Explain how this article will help contribute to your larger group project.
What is Statelessness?-UNHCR (file:///C:/Users/user/Documents/UNHCR-Statelessness-2pager-ENG.pdf)
This article helped me to get information about what actions might reduce or stop statelessness.
What is being discussed in the video? Explain your answer.
The video tells the story of Maha Mamo, a stateless person, who struggles to live and get citizenship. She got into a lot of trouble for not having an ID. She also tried to get citizenship but many refused, until one day she got his citizenship.
What is the speaker’s main purpose? Explain your answer.
the speaker provided information about how it feels to be statelessness and how difficult it is to get citizenship. He also hopes that countries out there can make it easier for statelessness to get citizenship and also eliminate gender discrimination which is one of the causes of statelessness.
How trustworthy is this video? Who is the speaker? What is the source? Do you think the source and the speaker are trustworthy?
this video is from TEDx Talks youtube channel. and the speaker is Maha Mamo. Maha Mamo is a former Statelessness, Brazil motivational speaker and human rights Activism, born in Lebanon to Syrians parents, who couldn’t get any citizenship due to her parent’s Religion, by restrictions stated in Syria and Lebanon nationality laws. (wikipedia). I think the source and the speaker are quite reliable because the speaker experienced these things when he was a child and he also included several photos during his speech as evidence
What the speaker’s attitude or tone towards the subject? Does he/she seem to agree or disagree with it? Explain your answer.
there was a look of sadness on the speaker’s face when he delivered a speech. he is sad because many people are like him. many people whose rights are not fulfilled.
Does the speaker put forward valid or strong arguments? How does he/she support the key points? Explain your answer.
the speaker talked about his past and also gave some solid evidence through photos.
Explain how this article will help contribute to your larger group project.
Background Note on gender equality, nationality laws and statelessness 2014- UNHCR (https://www.unhcr.org/4f5886306.pdf)
the article made me understand more about how gender differences can make a person statelessness. in the article also mentions the possible causes of a person being stateless which I never thought that something like that could happen